¾É½× 4/30/2010
¤@¡B °Ñ¦Ò®Ñ¥Ø¡G
Achtemeier, Paul J., Mark (Proclamation Commentaries). Philadelphia: Fortress, 1975.
Evans, Craig A, Mark 8:27-16:20. (World Biblical Commentary 34b). Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 2001.
Guelich, Robert A. Mark 1-8:26. (World Biblical Commentary 34a). Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 1989.
Garrett, Susan R. The Temptations of Jesus in Mark¡¦s Gospel. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998.
Metzger, Bruce M., The New Testament its Background, Growth, and Content. Nashville: Abingdon, 1975, 1983. (·s¬ù¾É½×¡A»´ä¡G°ò·þ±Ð¤åÃÀ¥Xª©ªÀ¡A1976)
Peabody, David B. Lamar Cope, and Allen J. McNicol. Editor. One Gospel from Two Mark¡¦s Use of Matthew and Luke: A Demonstration by the Research Team of the International Institute for Gospel Studies. Harrisburg, London, New York: Trinity Press International, 2002.
Power, Mark Allan, Fortress Introduction to the Gospels, Minneapolis, Fortress, 1998.
¿c«T¸q¡A °¨¥iºÖµ«H®§¹Å¸q¡G«HºÖ¡A1996¡C
§d¼z»ö¡A½Í±¡»¡²z¸Ü·s¬ù¡A »´ä¡G§ó·s¸ê·½¡A1998¡C
¤G¡B«e¨¥¡G
¸t¸g¾ÇªÌ±N°¨¤Ó¡B°¨¥i¡B¸ô¥[³o¤T¥»ºÖµ®ÑºÙ¬°¦@Æ[ºÖµ¡A¦]¬°¥¦Ì¶¡¦³®É¬Æ¦Ü¤@¦r¤£®t¡A¤]¦³«Ü¦h¬Û¦üªº¦a¤è¡C³o©M¬ù¿«ºÖµ§¹¥þ¤£¦P¡CY¥J²Ó¤ñ¸û¡A§ÚÌ·|µo²{¦@Æ[ºÖµ¶¡¤´¦³³\¦h®t§O¡C[1] ¦@Æ[ºÖµ§@ªÌ¦³¦U¦Ûªº¥ß³õ©M¥Øªº¡C¦p¡G°¨¤ÓºÖµªº¹ï¶H¥HµS¤Ó¤H¬°ÅªªÌ¡C¥Ñ©ó¼gµ¹µS¤Ó¤HŪ¡A¦]¦¹·í¹J¨ì¤W«Ò°ê®É¡A³£¨è·N§ï¦¨¤Ñ°ê¡CŪ¦@Æ[ºÖµ®Ñ³Ì¦n¬O±N³o¤T¥»ºÖµ®Ñ¹ï·ÓµÛŪ¡A¬Ý®t§O¦bþ¸Ì¡C¤ñ¤è¡G«C¦~°]¥D¡] ¤Ó19¡G16-30¡B¥i 10:17-31¡B ¸ô 18:18-30 ¡^¤¤ªº´yz¤À§O¬°¡G«C¦~¡B¦³¤H¡B¤@Ó©x¡C
¤T¡B¦¨®Ñ¦~¥N¡G
°¨¥iºÖµ®Ñ¬O¥|¥»ºÖµ®Ñ¤¤³Ìµuªº¤@¥»¡A¦]¦¹³Q»{¬°¬O³Ì¦¼g¦¨ªººÖµ®Ñ¡C[2]³Q»{¬°¬O¦@Æ[ºÖµªº©³¥»¡C¥¦¦b¦b64¦Ü70¦~¶¡¼gªº¡A©¼±o¬O¦b64¦Ü66¦~¶¡¡A¦]¥§¸S¬Ó«Ò¢®`°ò·þ®{®É®î±Ð¡C¦]¦¹§@ªÌ¼g¦¹®Ñ«HnÀ°§U¦bWÃø¤¤ªº«H®{««Ø¥L̪º«H¥õ¡A°í©w«H¤ß¡C§@ªÌ¦b¼g®Ñ®É«æ¢ªºì¦]¡C
¥|¡B §@ªÌ¡G
¥j¥N±Ð¤÷Ì¡APapias¥H¤Î¤§«áªº±Ð¤÷¡A¦p¡G150¦~¤Ú°Ç´µ©Z¤§®î¹DªÌõ¾Ç®a´å´µ¤B¡]Justin Martyr¡^¡A175¦~¤p¨È²Ó¨È¤§·R¥ô¯Ã¡]Irenaeus¡^¡A240¦~¨È¾ú¤s¤jªº«X§Q®Ú¡]Origen¡^ µ¥¦h¤H¡A»{¬°°¨¥i¬O©¼±oªº®{§Ì¡A©Ò¥H¸ê®Æ¬O¥Ñ©¼±o¤f±Â°ò·þ¦æz¡A¨Ã«D«ö·Ó®É§Ç°O¨Æ¡A¥BºÙ¥»®Ñ¬°©¼±oºÖµ®Ñ¡C[3] °¨¥iºÖµ¼gµ¹Ã¹°¨¤Hªº¡Aù°¨¤H¹ï©â¶H²z½×¤£´±¿³½ì¡A«oÁ¿¨D¦æ°Ê»P®Ä²v[4]¡C °¨¥iªº¥À¿Ë°¨§Q¨È¬O¦´ÁC¸ô¼»§N±Ð¹Îªº«n¥÷¤l¡C°¨¥i´¿¸ò©¼±o¡B¤Ú®³¤Ú¤@¦P¥h¶ÇºÖµ¡A«á¨Ó¤]´¿¬O«Oùªº¦P¤u¡]®{13:5¡^¡C
¤¡B ¥»®Ñªº¯SÂI¦p¤U¡G
A. §@ªÌ±NC¿q¶ÇºÖµ¨Æ¤uªº«ÂI©ñ¦b¥[§Q§Q¡C
1¡G9¡A ¹L¤F¤£¤[¡AC¿q±q¥[§Q§Q¬Ùªº®³¼»°Ç¨Ó¡C
1¡G14¡A¬ù¿«³QÃö¶iºÊº»¥H«á¡AC¿q¨ì¥[§Q§Q¥h¡C
1¡G16¡AC¿qªuµÛ¥[§Q§Q´òÃ䨫¡A¬Ý¨£¨âÓ¥´³½ªº¡C
1¡G28¡A©ó¬OC¿qªº¦WÁn«Ü§Ö¦a¶Ç¹M¤F¥[§Q§Q¦a°Ï¡C
1¡G39¡A©ó¬OC¿q¨«¹M¤F¥[§Q§Q¥þ¹Ò¡A¦b¦U·|°ó¸Ì¶Ç¹D¡A¨Ã¥B»°°¡C
1¡G13¡A C¿q¦A¨ì¥[§Q§Q´òÃä¡A¤@¤j¸s¤H»E¶°¦b¥L¨Ãä¡A¥L´N±Ð¾É¥LÌ¡C
3¡G7¡A C¿q©Mªù®{ÌÂ÷¶}¨º¸Ì¨ì¥[§Q§Q´òÃä¥h¡A¤@¤j¸s¤H¸òµÛ¥L¡C
3¡G8¡A ¥L̬O±q¥[§Q§Q¡BµS¤Ó¡BC¸ô¼»§N¡B¥H¤g¶R¡B¬ù¥¹ªe¹ï©¤µ¥¡K¡C
4¡G1¡A C¿q¤S¦b¥[§Q§Q´òÃä±Ð¾É¤H¡C
5¡G1¡A ¥L̨Өì¥[§Q§Q´òªº¨º¤@Ãä¡AÄÝ©ó®æ©Ô´Ë¤Hªº¦a°Ï¡C
7¡G31¡A C¿qÂ÷¶}®õº¸ªþªñ¦a°Ï¡A¸g¹L¦è¹y¡A±q¤Q¨¶¹Ò¬É¦^¨ì¥[§Q§Q´ò¡C
9¡G30¡A¥LÌÂ÷¶}¤F¨º¦a¤è¡A¸g¹L¥[§Q§Q¡C
14¡G28¡A¡u¦ý¬O§Ú´_¬¡¥H«á¡An¤ñ§AÌ¥ý¨ì¥[§Q§Q¥h¡C¡v
15¡G40-47¡A´N¬OC¿q¦b¥[§Q§Qªº®ÉÔ¡A¸òÀH¥L¡BªA¨Æ¥Lªº¨º¨Ç¤H¡AÁÙ¦³¦PC¿q¤WC¸ô¼»§Nªº¦n¨Ç°ü¤k¦b¨ºùØÆ[¬Ý¡C
16¡G7¡A§A̧֥h§i¶D¥Lªºªù®{¡A¤×¨ä¬O©¼±o¡A»¡¡G¡y¥Ln¤ñ§AÌ¥ý¨ì¥[§Q§Q¥h¡A¦b¨º¸Ì§AÌ¥i¥H¨£¨ì¥L¡A¥¿¹³¥L±q«e§i¶D¹L§A̪º¡C
B. ¥»®Ñ¤jÅé¤W¬O«ö·Ó©Òµo¥Í®É¶¡ªº¦¸§Ç¼gªº¡C¥¦ÁöµM¬O¥|ºÖµ®Ñ¤¤³Ìµuªº¤@¨÷¡A¦ý¥¦©Ò°Oªº¾ú¥v¨Æ¹ê¡A¤ñ¨ä¥L¤T¨÷ºÖµ®Ñ§ó¸ÔºÉ¡C¥»®Ñ²¤¹LC¿qªº¥X¥Í¡A¥u°OzÍ¢¤½¶}ªA¨Æªº¤ù¬q¡A±j½ÕÍ¢«á´ÁªºªA¨Æ¡A¥Î¤T¤À¤§¤@ªº½g´T±Ôz¨üÃø¸g¹L¡C
C. ¥»®Ñ¤¤ªº¥DC¿q¡AÅãµM¥H¹²¤Hªº«ººA¥X²{¡A¬G´yzÍ¢ªº¤u§@¨ÆÂÝ¡A°¾«¦bÂå¯f¡B»°°µ¥¯«ÂÝ©_¨Æ¡A¦Ó¤Ö¦³ªø½g±Ð°V©M¤ñ³ë¡F¦]¬°¹²¤H©y©ó¤Ö»¡¸Ü¡A¦h§@¨Æ¡C ¬JµMC¿q¬O¹²¤H¡A¦]¦¹·¥¶Ô³Ò¡AÍ¢¦b³°¦a¡B®ü¬v©ÎÃm³¥¡A±q¦¨ì±ß¦£¤£°±¡A¤é¸¨¤FÁÙ¦£µÛÂåªv¯f¤H(1:32)¡Aª½¨ì²`©]¡F¦¸¤é¤Ñ¥¼«G´N°_¨Ó(1:35)¡C³o¼Ë¤Ö¦³·²®§ªº®É¶¡¡A¬Æ¦Ü³s¦Y¶ºªº¤u¤Ò¤]¨S¦³(3:20¡F6:31)¡A¥HPÍ¢ªº¿ËÄݳ£»¡Í¢¬OÅö¨g¤F(3:21)¡C¬G¥Î¦r¤]¯S§O¡A¦p¡GÍ¢³Q¸tÆF¡y»°¡z¨ìÃm³¥¨üÅ]°¸Õ±´(1:12)¡C°¨¥iºÖµ¦b°ò·þ®{¨ü¨ì¢®`ªººò«æ±¡ªp¤U¡A´N¬O»°§Ö´yzC¿qªº¬@±Ï¡C§@ªÌ¥Î©M¡B¤Î¡B©Îµ¥³s±µµü¡A¯S§O¬O¥ß§Y©Î¨º®É¦b¤Q¤»³¹·í¤¤¥X²{¥|¤Q¦h¦¸¡A¨ä¥L¦p¡G¤@¤W¨Ó (1:10; 21)¡B´N (1:12)¡B¥ß¨è (1:18) µ¥¦b²Ä¤@³¹´Nºò´ê¥X²{¡C¥ÎÃþ¦ü¡u¥ß¨è¡v¡B¡uÀH§Y¡vªºµü¹F¥|¤Q¦h¦¸¡A¥HÅã©úÍ¢ªº¤u§@´XµL¶¡Â_¡C [5]
¤»¡B ¦¹®Ñ¤À¦¨´XÓ¬q¸¨¡G
1¡B1:1-13¡G§Ç¨¥¡A¤¶²Ð¬I¬~¬ù¿«¡C 2¡B1:14-8:26¡GC¿q°ò·þªº«Å±Ð¨Æ¤u¡C 3¡B8:27-10:31¡G¹w¨¥¨üÃø¡A·Ç³Æ¨«¦VC¸ô¼»§N¡C 4¡B10:32-52¡G©¹C¸ô¼»§N«°¡C 5¡B11:1-14-31¡G¦bC¸ô¼»§N¦a°Ïªº¬¡°Ê¡C 6¡B²Ä14:32-15:47¡G¨üÃø¡B®I¸®¡C 7¡B16:1-8¡G´_¬¡ªº¨ÆÂÝ¡C 8¡B16:9-20¡GÅã²{»P¤É¤Ñ
ª`ÄÀ¡G
¦@Æ[(¹ïÆ[)ºÖµ¡]Synpotic Gospels¡^ªº°²»¡¡C³Ì«nªº¬OÂù·½»¡ (Two Source Hypothesis)¡G¥|¥»ºÖµ®Ñ¤¤¡A°¨¥i³Ì¦¼g¦¨¡C°¨¤Ó©M¸ô¥[³£±Ä¥Î¤F°¨¥iªº§÷®Æ¡C¤§¥~°¨¤Ó©M¸ô¥[³£±Ä¥ÎQ¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½ (Quelle¬°¼w¤å¨Ó·½)¡AQ¤j³¡¤À¬OC¿qªº±Ð°V¡C°¨¤Ó©M¸ô¥[ÁÙ¦³¦U¦Û¿W¯Sªº¸ê®Æ¨Ó·½¥ÎM¡BL¸ê®Æªí¥Ü¡C
Q¬O°²³]¤å¥ó¬O°¨¥i¨S¦³¡A¦ý°¨¤Ó©M¸ô¥[³£¦³ªº°O¸ü¡C¨Ò¦p¡G¡u§A̬è¨D´Nµ¹§AÌ¡D´M§ä´N´M¨£¡D¥nªù´Nµ¹§A̶}ªù¡v¥i¨£©ó°¨¤Ó©M¸ô¥[ (¤Ó7:7¡A¸ô11:9)¡A¤]¨£©ó¦h°¨ºÖµ¡Ano. 94¡C ¦h°¨ºÖµ¡]The Gospel of Thomas¡^¬y¶Ç©óªì¥N±Ð·|¡A«á¨Ó³vº¥¤£¬°¤Hª¾¡A20¥@¬öªì¦Ò¥j¾Ç®aµo²{§Æþ¤å´Ý½g¡C1945¦~¬ì´¶¯S¤å(Coptic)¦h°¨ºÖµ¦Û®J¤Î¯Ç®æ«¢°¨¦a(Nag Hammadi)¥X¤g«á¡A¥þ»ª¤~¦A²{¦b¥@¤H±«e¡C§@ªÌ¦ÛºÙ¬°C¿qªù®{¦h°¨¡A¤º®e¬OC¿q±Ð¾Éªù®{ªº°O¿ý¡A³QºÙ¬°C¿q¯µ±K¸Ü»y¡CºÖµ¦³114¬q¡C¥¦§âC¿q¹ï¤Ñ°êªº»{ÃÑ»P°ò·þ®{ªº¹ê½î¦³§óª½±µªº±Ð¾É¡C³o³¡ºÖµ¥i¥H¥Ñ¯«¾Ç±Ð¸q¡B¾ú¥v¦Ò¾Ú¡B¤åÄm¤ñ¹ïµ¥¤£¦PÆ[ÂI¨Ó¬ã¨s¡C
[2] 125¦~¬ù¿«ªºªù¥Í¡A±Ð¤÷Papias »{¬°°¨¤Ó¤ñ°¨¥i§ó¦§¹¦¨¡A¤S°¨¤ÓºÖµªº§@ªÌ³Q»{¬°¬OC¿qªºªù®{¡A¦]¦¹¥L§â°¨¤ÓºÖµ±Æ¦C©ó°¨¥iºÖµ¤§«e¡C¦ý¦Û±qÂù·½»¡¤§«á¡A¸t¸g¾Ç¬É³£»{¬°°¨¥i¬OºÖµ®Ñªº©³¥»¡C¦ý³Ìªñ¦³¤@§å¤H»{¬°°¨¥iºÖµ¥H°¨¤Ó©M¸ô¥[¬°©³¥»¡C¨£One Gospel from Two Mark¡¦s Use of Matthew and Luke¡C
[3] §õ¹D¥Í¡m·s¬ù°ÝÃDÁ`¸Ñ¡n¡Aºô¸ôª©¡C
[4] §d¼z»ö¡A½Í±¡»¡²z¸Ü·s¬ù¡App. 56-57¡C
[5]¡u¤@...´N¡v¡]1:10¡A29¡F5:2¡F15:1)¡B¡u¥ß¨è¡v(1:18¡A30¡A43¡F12¡F3:6¡F4:15¡A16¡A17¡F5:29¡F6:54¡F10:52)¡B¡uÀH§Y¡v(1:20¡A21¡F6:27¡A45¡F8:10¡F14:45)¡B¡u´N¡v(1:30¡A43¡F4:29¡F6:25¡F7:35)¡B¡u§Y®É¡v(1:42)¡B¡u(¥ß¨è)ª¾¹D¡v(2:8)¡B¡u(¥ß¨è)¦P¡v(3:6)¡B¡u³Ì§Ö¡v(4:5)¡B¡uµn®É¡v(5:30)¡B¡u¥ß®É¡v(5:42¡F9:24¡F11:3)¡B¡u³s¦£¡v(6:50)¡B¡u(¥ß¨è)»{¥X¡v(6:54)¡B¡u¤@¡v(¤E15¡A20¡F¤Q¤@2)¡B¡u©¿µM¡v(¤Q¥|43) ¡C